On November 10, Councilman Alvaro Medeiros walked the Township Council through nine slides describing a rent stabilization ordinance that is expected to be introduced after public discussion.

As presented, the ordinance would do the following for covered apartments:

  • Limit annual rent increases to 4 percent or the change in the Consumer Price Index, whichever is lower.
  • Limit the increase to 10 percent when a tenant moves out and a new one moves in.
  • Require every covered landlord to register each unit, its rent and its lease dates with the Township every year. No registration, no increase.
  • Create a five-member Rent Stabilization Board, with two alternates, and a Township administrator to take complaints and decide disputes.
  • Require a landlord who says the cap is too low to submit two years of income and expense statements, state the rate of return desired and the reason for it, and carry the burden of proof while the board decides whether that return is reasonable.

Read the last one again. A Township board would decide how much a private owner may earn.

So here is my question for Mr. Medeiros and the Council: Should Berkeley Heights cap the price of pizza, too?

Where is the line?

I am not being flip. Suppose a pizzeria raises the price of a pie by 10 percent. People on fixed incomes have to eat. If the Township may decide that a 10 percent rent increase is unreasonable, may it decide the same about a pie? A haircut? An oil change? Should the pizzeria owner bring two years of books to a Township board and explain the profit he would like to make?

If the answer is no, residents deserve to hear why rent is different. "Housing is important" is not a principle. Food is important, too.

The law does not draw the line for us. The New Jersey Supreme Court held in 1973, in Inganamort v. Borough of Fort Lee, that a town may regulate rents. The power it relied on is the general police power in N.J.S.A. 40:48-2, the same statute behind ordinary health, safety and welfare ordinances. There is no special rent statute.

Two years later, in Hutton Park Gardens v. West Orange, the court said that for constitutional purposes rent control is "indistinguishable from other types of governmental price regulation," and it compared renting apartments to selling food at retail. The main limit the court set was that an efficient owner must be allowed a just and reasonable return.

I am not a lawyer, and I am not claiming a pizza cap would survive in court. I know of no New Jersey court that has approved one. My point is narrower. Once a council accepts that it may set one private price and judge one owner's profit, the stopping point is mostly a matter of political judgment. So the Council should say where it intends to stop.

Is this socialism? Not by the textbook definition. The Township would not own the buildings, and New Jersey towns have used rent control for decades. But a government board ruling on what a private owner may charge and earn is government control of both the price and the profit. Every business owner in town is entitled to ask whether the same reasoning reaches them next.

It may not reach the building that started this

The complaint behind the proposal is real. Mr. Medeiros said at the July 21 Council meeting that residents of Woodcrest, a 55-and-over rental community on Locust Avenue, received 10 percent renewal increases, his mother among them, and that requests for relief were turned down. That is hard on a fixed income, and I do not dismiss it. He has since told me that his mother no longer lives there.

But a 1987 state law, N.J.S.A. 2A:42-84.1 through 84.6, exempts newly built apartment buildings of four or more units from municipal rent control for up to 30 years. It also bars a town from adopting any ordinance that limits or impairs that exemption. On August 11, Mr. Medeiros told the Council that Woodcrest "squarely falls" under it.

The state law does carve out senior housing. It defines senior citizens as people 62 and older, and Mr. Medeiros has described Woodcrest as a 55-and-over community. Assemblyman Vincent Kearney introduced a bill on October 5, A5585, to extend the carve-out to 55-and-over housing. As introduced, it would apply only to tenancies that begin after it becomes law, and it has not been enacted.

The large apartment buildings that have gone up around town in recent years are new construction. So which buildings would this ordinance actually cover on the day it takes effect, and how many apartments are in them? The slides do not say.

If the honest answer is a few older buildings, the Township would be standing up a board, an administrator and a registration system that state law may keep away from the very rents that prompted it.

What would it cost?

The plan calls for a board of five members and two alternates, a Township employee serving as administrator, support from the Township attorney, annual registrations and public hearings. Mr. Medeiros said on November 10 that he was told the work would be part-time. The slides contain no cost figure. Residents should see one before the ordinance is introduced.

What the evidence says

In February 2012, the University of Chicago's panel of leading economists was asked whether local limits on rent increases had improved the amount and quality of affordable rental housing in cities that used them. Eighty-one percent disagreed. Two percent agreed.

A 2019 study in the American Economic Review looked at San Francisco's expansion of rent control. It found that tenants already in place were more likely to stay. It also found that affected landlords reduced the supply of rental housing by 15 percent by selling to owner-occupants and redeveloping.

That is the trade: protection for today's tenants, fewer apartments for tomorrow's.

A better place to protect renters

Mr. Medeiros noted on July 21 that Woodcrest has a PILOT agreement with the Township. The Township negotiates those agreements. That is the moment it has leverage.

When that deal was negotiated, did anyone ask for limits on renewal increases for senior tenants? Can future redevelopment and financial agreements include them? The Council should ask the Township attorney and publish the answer. A term an owner accepts in exchange for a tax break is a different thing from a price set by ordinance after the building is open.

Four things to do before introduction

  1. Publish the full text. Residents have seen nine slides, not the ordinance.
  2. List every building, with unit counts, that would be covered on day one, and every building exempt under state law.
  3. State the annual cost of the board, the administrator and the attorney's time.
  4. Say plainly who is covered. As presented, the ordinance applies to buildings or developments with four or more rental units, not to a resident who rents out a house or a two-family. That is a slide. The definition in the text is what counts, and a later ordinance can change the number.

If the Council can explain why it should set the price of an apartment and not the price of a pizza, good. Let's hear it before the vote, not after.

An invitation to Councilman Medeiros

We would like to hear Councilman Medeiros respond to this article. He knows this proposal better than anyone, and residents deserve his answers to the questions above: where the line is, which buildings are covered and what it will cost.

Disclosure: I was a candidate for Berkeley Heights Township Council in the November 2026 election.

Updated November 15, 2026: An earlier version of this column asked whether Mr. Medeiros should recuse. He has told me his mother no longer lives at Woodcrest, and I have removed that section.

Sources